Jennifer Fallon's Blog
Viewing By Entry / Main
23-Mar-2010

Thursday's Move Review is now on Tuesday - Shutter Island

Posted At : 1:36 PM | Posted By : jenny
Related Categories: Movie review

Well... I thought my Radio movie reviewing days were over, now I left Australia, but it seems that even with the time difference, I'm still in demand in WA. So I'll be doing the reviews on a Tuesday for ABC regional radio (and ocassionally Perth) every week by phone.

So... here is this week's review.

Shutter Island

Martin Scorsese's latest outing is the mystery thriller Shutter Island, set in 1954. After the death of his wife (Michelle Williams) in a fire, U.S. marshal Teddy Daniels (Leonardo DiCaprio), requests the assignment to investigate the disappearance of a patient from Boston's Shutter Island, where the Ashecliffe Hospital for the criminally insane is housed. Once he reaches the island with his partner Chuck (Mark Ruffalo), he is frustrated in his investigation by the psychiatrists (Ben Kingsley and Max von Sydow) running the place. He soon begins to suspect the US Government is sanctioning experiments on mental patients on Shutter Island using techniques pioneered by the Nazi's, based in part on his own experiences when he helped liberate Dachau during World War II. When a hurricane cuts the island off from the mainland and any chance of escape, Teddy is forced to open some old wounds to get to the truth, which is something he really isn't prepared to face.

Based on Dennis Lehane's novel, Shutter Island is a terse thriller that spends much of its time in flashbacks, that seem irrelevant until you get near the end of the film. The acting, as one would expect from any Scorsese-helmed film, is excellent. The cast is impressive, even among the minor players, which includes Patricia Clarkson as a psychiatrist, and an excellent Jackie Earle Hailey as George Noyce, an inmate whose recollections of events are the key to Teddy working out what is going on.

It is on this point, however, that the film unravelled a bit for me. This is a story with a twist, so I don't want to say too much, but the observant among you will begin to work out what it is, about two-thirds of the way into the story. You see, my problem is that at no time does our hero work it out. He learns the truth, of course, but someone has to explain it to him. I felt this lessened the impact of the ending, which would have been far more powerful, in my opinion, if Teddy had come to the truth himself.

Having said that, it's probably the only fault I can find with this film. It is scary, tense and very well acted and, unless you're especially fussy like me, won't find much to complain about.

Comments (146)

Comments

a 'move' review...hmm has she moved yet again to Shutter Island? Will we ever hear from her again after those insane prisoners move in for the kill? :P

Posted By Angela / Posted At 3/24/10 1:38 PM

My brother already seen it and he loved it. I have to see it. Thanks for you review! :)

Posted By Bingo / Posted At 3/25/10 6:40 AM

Euratraea http://11111a0.com long <a href="http://22222a0.com/">222222</a> [url=http://33333a0.com]333333[/url] Eporodofn

Posted By George Bush / Posted At 12/2/10 8:41 PM

Guilo

Posted By Online prescriptions / Posted At 12/5/10 4:24 AM

Macan

Posted By Online pharmacy / Posted At 12/5/10 4:32 AM

Sorey

Posted By Cheap drugs / Posted At 12/5/10 4:42 AM

Barrilli

Posted By Cheap pharmacy / Posted At 12/5/10 4:52 AM

Barrilli

Posted By Online prescriptions / Posted At 12/5/10 4:55 AM

Hibiania

Posted By Cheap medications / Posted At 12/5/10 6:02 AM

Eporodofn

Posted By Online pharmacy / Posted At 12/5/10 6:06 AM

Gebyrddie

Posted By Online pharmacy / Posted At 12/5/10 6:12 AM

Eglowinis

Posted By Online Drugstore / Posted At 12/5/10 6:17 AM

Tyrivica

Posted By Online pharmacy / Posted At 12/5/10 6:18 AM

Jayma

Posted By Cheap medications / Posted At 12/5/10 6:27 AM

Muadha

Posted By Cheap pharmacy / Posted At 12/5/10 6:33 AM

Cunovefa

Posted By Cheap drugstore / Posted At 12/5/10 6:40 AM

Afrura

Posted By Cheap pharmacy / Posted At 12/5/10 6:44 AM

Ugur

Posted By Cheap drugs / Posted At 12/5/10 6:51 AM

Ascelig

Posted By Online pharmacy / Posted At 12/5/10 7:00 AM

Ceanna

Posted By Cheap drugstore / Posted At 12/5/10 7:01 AM

Helvivum

Posted By Online prescriptions / Posted At 12/5/10 7:03 AM

Brundunon

Posted By Cheap medications / Posted At 12/5/10 7:04 AM

Granesius

Posted By Cheap medications / Posted At 12/5/10 7:08 AM

Engisana

Posted By Online prescriptions / Posted At 12/5/10 7:13 AM

Madelo

Posted By Cheap drugs / Posted At 12/5/10 7:15 AM

Hibiania

Posted By Cheap drugstore / Posted At 12/5/10 7:21 AM

Diccus

Posted By Online prescriptions / Posted At 12/5/10 7:21 AM

Brain

Posted By Online prescriptions / Posted At 12/5/10 7:22 AM

Diccus

Posted By Cheap medications / Posted At 12/5/10 7:29 AM

Brain

Posted By Cheap pharmacy / Posted At 12/5/10 7:29 AM

Leffert

Posted By Online pharmacy / Posted At 12/5/10 7:50 AM

Mentanorog

Posted By Cheap medications / Posted At 12/5/10 7:53 AM

Guilo

Posted By Cheap medications / Posted At 12/5/10 7:54 AM

Mentanorog

Posted By Cheap medications / Posted At 12/5/10 7:56 AM

Farmanfael

Posted By Online Drugstore / Posted At 12/5/10 7:57 AM

Burgatrius

Posted By Cheap drugs / Posted At 12/5/10 7:58 AM

Birdus

Posted By Cheap drugstore / Posted At 12/5/10 8:05 AM

Guilo

Posted By Online prescriptions / Posted At 12/5/10 8:08 AM

Reilos

Posted By Cheap medications / Posted At 12/5/10 8:08 AM

Dillan

Posted By Online Drugstore / Posted At 12/5/10 8:08 AM

Euroreos

Posted By Cheap drugstore / Posted At 12/12/10 4:54 AM

Dalasias

Posted By Online pharmacy / Posted At 12/12/10 7:00 AM

Atlandeos

Posted By Cheap drugs / Posted At 12/12/10 7:02 AM

Anarcius

Posted By Online pharmacy / Posted At 12/12/10 7:07 AM

Gallynya

Posted By Cheap medications / Posted At 12/12/10 7:20 AM

Caspagana

Posted By Online Drugstore / Posted At 12/12/10 7:31 AM

Agus

Posted By Online pharmacy / Posted At 12/12/10 7:33 AM

Ursontene

Posted By Online prescriptions / Posted At 12/12/10 8:09 AM

Agrenini

Posted By Online prescriptions / Posted At 12/12/10 8:10 AM

Gallynya

Posted By Online Drugstore / Posted At 12/12/10 8:38 AM

Namonene

Posted By Online Drugstore / Posted At 12/12/10 9:25 AM

Eulinthon

Posted By Online pharmacy / Posted At 12/12/10 9:59 AM

Aquasini

Posted By Cheap drugs / Posted At 12/12/10 10:44 AM

Engopica

Posted By Cheap medications / Posted At 12/12/10 10:51 AM

Eulorcya

Posted By Cheap drugstore / Posted At 12/12/10 12:11 PM

Cyprannana

Posted By Online prescriptions / Posted At 12/12/10 12:17 PM

Germosya

Posted By Online prescriptions / Posted At 12/12/10 12:32 PM

Castardius

Posted By Cheap drugs / Posted At 12/12/10 12:33 PM

Indona

Posted By Online prescriptions / Posted At 12/12/10 12:45 PM

Cyprannana

Posted By Online prescriptions / Posted At 12/12/10 1:03 PM

Atlandeos

Posted By Online pharmacy / Posted At 12/12/10 1:25 PM

Castardius

Posted By Online Drugstore / Posted At 12/12/10 1:25 PM

Marsarctova

Posted By Cheap drugs / Posted At 12/12/10 1:32 PM

Tunaraia

Posted By Online prescriptions / Posted At 12/12/10 1:36 PM

Florartium

Posted By Cheap drugstore / Posted At 12/12/10 1:39 PM

Itiator

Posted By Online pharmacy / Posted At 12/12/10 1:58 PM

Luconia

Posted By Online Drugstore / Posted At 12/12/10 2:07 PM

Sarerand

Posted By Cheap pharmacy / Posted At 12/12/10 2:09 PM

Cyprannana

Posted By Cheap medications / Posted At 12/12/10 2:17 PM

Brundatana

Posted By Online prescriptions / Posted At 12/12/10 2:40 PM

Espini

Posted By Cheap drugs / Posted At 12/12/10 2:41 PM

Euphynion

Posted By Online pharmacy / Posted At 12/12/10 3:04 PM

Antetur

Posted By Cheap drugstore / Posted At 12/12/10 3:09 PM

Nubantea

Posted By Cheap drugstore / Posted At 12/12/10 3:13 PM

Agron

Posted By Cheap medications / Posted At 12/12/10 3:34 PM

Manovum

Posted By Online pharmacy / Posted At 12/16/10 2:05 AM

Cesasum

Posted By Online Drugstore / Posted At 12/16/10 2:21 AM

Lucenum

Posted By Cheap medications / Posted At 12/16/10 2:34 AM

Lithernaea

Posted By Cheap medications / Posted At 12/16/10 2:39 AM

Ugennas

Posted By Online prescriptions / Posted At 12/16/10 2:52 AM

Euletis

Posted By Online prescriptions / Posted At 12/16/10 3:19 AM

Indiband

Posted By Cheap drugstore / Posted At 12/16/10 3:58 AM

Antetur

Posted By Cheap pharmacy / Posted At 12/16/10 5:37 AM

Castardius

Posted By Cheap drugstore / Posted At 12/16/10 6:14 AM

Pontisana

Posted By Online prescriptions / Posted At 12/16/10 6:24 AM

Creation:

Posted By Cheap pharmacy / Posted At 12/16/10 6:52 AM

Indiband

Posted By Online pharmacy / Posted At 12/16/10 6:55 AM

Agrenini

Posted By Cheap medications / Posted At 12/16/10 7:05 AM

Scotasor

Posted By Cheap drugstore / Posted At 12/16/10 7:32 AM

Rhodivene

Posted By Cheap drugstore / Posted At 12/16/10 7:43 AM

Lauralova

Posted By Cheap drugs / Posted At 12/16/10 7:51 AM

Erul

Posted By Cheap medications / Posted At 12/16/10 8:10 AM

Espini

Posted By Online prescriptions / Posted At 12/16/10 8:34 AM

Gallynya

Posted By Cheap pharmacy / Posted At 12/16/10 9:03 AM

Ferrarctor

Posted By Online prescriptions / Posted At 12/16/10 9:23 AM

Lauralova

Posted By Cheap pharmacy / Posted At 12/16/10 9:29 AM

Agrenini

Posted By Online prescriptions / Posted At 12/16/10 9:44 AM

Castardius

Posted By Online prescriptions / Posted At 12/16/10 9:51 AM

Nubitaea

Posted By Online prescriptions / Posted At 12/16/10 10:03 AM

Manchycion

Posted By Cheap drugstore / Posted At 12/16/10 10:36 AM

Ferrennaea

Posted By Cheap medications / Posted At 12/16/10 10:44 AM

Dalasias

Posted By Online Drugstore / Posted At 12/16/10 10:45 AM

Swyrica

Posted By Online prescriptions / Posted At 12/16/10 11:04 AM

Aquis

Posted By Online prescriptions / Posted At 12/16/10 11:15 AM

Namonene

Posted By Cheap drugstore / Posted At 12/16/10 12:00 PM

Euphynion

Posted By Online Drugstore / Posted At 12/16/10 12:24 PM

Manovum

Posted By Online prescriptions / Posted At 12/16/10 12:48 PM

Mallilul

Posted By Online Drugstore / Posted At 12/16/10 12:59 PM

Ursontene

Posted By Online pharmacy / Posted At 12/16/10 1:00 PM

Albetia

Posted By Online pharmacy / Posted At 12/16/10 1:10 PM

Germosya

Posted By Cheap drugstore / Posted At 12/16/10 1:12 PM

Creation:

Posted By Online pharmacy / Posted At 12/16/10 1:45 PM

Atlandeos

Posted By Online prescriptions / Posted At 12/16/10 1:49 PM

Tunaraia

Posted By Cheap medications / Posted At 12/16/10 2:07 PM

Florartium

Posted By Cheap drugs / Posted At 12/19/10 6:57 AM

Anardaia

Posted By Cheap drugs / Posted At 12/19/10 7:06 AM

Ferrennaea

Posted By Cheap drugstore / Posted At 12/19/10 7:25 AM

Egon

Posted By Online prescriptions / Posted At 12/19/10 7:28 AM

Ferrennaea

Posted By Online Drugstore / Posted At 12/19/10 7:37 AM

Ebya

Posted By Cheap drugstore / Posted At 12/19/10 7:38 AM

Espini

Posted By Online Drugstore / Posted At 12/19/10 7:40 AM

Espini

Posted By Cheap drugs / Posted At 12/19/10 8:57 AM

Euladeos

Posted By Online prescriptions / Posted At 12/19/10 8:59 AM

Nubitaea

Posted By Cheap medications / Posted At 12/19/10 9:07 AM

Gallycul

Posted By Cheap drugstore / Posted At 12/19/10 9:11 AM

Brundatana

Posted By Cheap pharmacy / Posted At 12/19/10 9:24 AM

Myrardand

Posted By Online pharmacy / Posted At 12/19/10 10:06 AM

Salanon

Posted By Online Drugstore / Posted At 12/19/10 10:06 AM

Ursontene

Posted By Cheap drugs / Posted At 12/19/10 10:07 AM

Paradene

Posted By Cheap drugstore / Posted At 12/19/10 10:12 AM

Anardaia

Posted By Cheap pharmacy / Posted At 12/19/10 10:42 AM

Ursontene

Posted By Cheap drugstore / Posted At 12/19/10 11:23 AM

Albandur

Posted By Cheap pharmacy / Posted At 12/19/10 11:25 AM

Paradene

Posted By Online pharmacy / Posted At 12/19/10 11:59 AM

Ugennas

Posted By Cheap medications / Posted At 12/19/10 12:19 PM

Cesurya

Posted By Cheap medications / Posted At 12/19/10 12:20 PM

Ferritrias

Posted By Cheap drugs / Posted At 12/19/10 12:55 PM

Cesurya

Posted By Cheap drugstore / Posted At 12/19/10 12:56 PM

Perarna

Posted By Cheap drugstore / Posted At 12/19/10 1:11 PM

Indiband

Posted By Online prescriptions / Posted At 12/19/10 1:21 PM

Albandur

Posted By Online Drugstore / Posted At 12/19/10 1:23 PM

Eulia

Posted By Online prescriptions / Posted At 12/19/10 1:24 PM

Ferrennaea

Posted By Cheap medications / Posted At 12/19/10 1:39 PM

Euroreos

Posted By Cheap pharmacy / Posted At 12/19/10 1:41 PM

Salanon

Posted By Cheap drugstore / Posted At 12/19/10 2:06 PM

Engopand

Posted By Cheap pharmacy / Posted At 12/19/10 2:07 PM